The Understanding Project
  • Logic
  • About
  • Author
  • Books

What Are Rights?

12/11/2010

 
I wasn’t aware of any disagreement between my peers. I thought that everyone had the same sense of fairness; it was just that some people were jerks or bullies. Even if there may have been some disagreement over what our rights were, I assumed that everyone knew what a “right” was. Then I grew up and was exposed to the world of politics.

To me, there have always been some absolutes. It is fundamentally wrong to take from one person, even if “more good” might be done by doing so to help others. It is fundamentally wrong to punish an entire classroom (or ethnic group) for the crimes of a few simply because the authorities cannot name the guilty parties. People have certain rights that exist independently of any “greater good”, however it is measured.

So I was very confused when some began to claim we had a “right to health care” and that this required state intervention. We have a right to free speech, but that doesn’t mean others must listen or even provide the platforms. We have a right to bear arms, but that doesn’t mean that others must build them for us at no cost. Guns are expensive. Since health care requires health care providers, the right to health care, as it is used today, is really identical to the right to own slaves. It is really identical to the right to violate others’ rights to freedom, and that would be wrong.

After reading around at different blogs, I think I finally got it. My theory is that some people either have no concept of rights as I know them, or else call them by a different name. “Rights” to these people are anything that is good. If they think that universal health care is good, then it becomes a right (even if it means telling private companies how to conduct their business). If they think higher education is good, it becomes a right (even if paying for it bankrupts the rest of us). If they think safety on aircraft is good, it becomes a right (even if it means intrusive searches and detaining people by ethnic group). So long as there is a greater good being done (by their measure), it is “right” to do so.

Of course, some of these things are good, or at least there is good in them, but that doesn’t make them right. I came up with this theory after I heard one of these people claim that it is those of us who are against this that do not understand that there are tradeoffs between the different rights. On the contrary, we are keenly aware of such things. In fact, we assumed that it was the others who did not understand this.

So, what’s your experience? Do you fall in my category, the other category, or some third category I am unaware of?

Of course, this doesn’t explain why others have a different moral sense than I do. Is it a genetic?

Sunny B. link
12/27/2010 03:20:33 am

Dan:

There are "negative" and "positive" rights.

The government can't take away "megative" rights. Freedom of speech and the right to bear arms are examples of negative rights.

A promise of government to provide health care or social security or public education to all are examples of positive rights.

You might bde confusing rights and liberities.

Here's a link that might be helpful:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_and_positive_rights

Daniel Noe link
12/30/2010 03:53:58 am

Thanks for the link. I wasn't familiar with all those distinctions, but no, I wasn't confusing rights and liberties. I suppose what I was trying to say was that I never (until recently) thought of positive rights (unless guaranteed by contract) as rights at all and never heard them called rights. I grew up with only negative rights being called rights.


Comments are closed.

    Author

    Hi, I'm Dan. I like chocolate, hiking, and politics.

    Archives

    November 2019
    April 2019
    February 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    May 2013
    November 2012
    October 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    February 2012
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    June 2010
    May 2010

    Categories

    All
    Abortion
    Al Gore
    Anarchy
    Animals
    Ann Coulter
    Anti-Semitism
    Approval Rate
    Barack Obama
    Bias
    Bill Clinton
    Budget Deficit
    Bush Bashing
    Bush-Bashing
    Bush-bashing
    Capitalism
    Center
    Christmas
    Civility
    Code Words
    Coffee Parties
    Collectivism
    Compromise
    Conservative
    Constitution
    Court Rulings
    Culture
    Debate
    Democrats
    Dick Cheney
    Discrimination
    Donald Trump
    Drew Weston
    Economy
    Education
    Environment
    Eric Holder
    Euthanasia
    Experience
    Flag Burning
    France
    George W Bush
    Glenn Beck
    Global Warming
    Health Care
    Hillary Clinton
    Historical Narrative
    Holiday
    Homosexual
    Huffington Post
    Humor
    Hypocrisy
    Immigration
    Independent
    Insult
    Insurance
    Iraq
    Israel
    Jared Loughner
    Jimmy Buffet
    John Kerry
    John Mccain
    Jon Stewart
    Joseph Stark
    Journalism
    Judith Curry
    Julian Assange
    Koran
    Liberal
    Libya
    Marginalization
    Marketing
    Marriage
    Media
    Memes
    Mike Huckabee
    Military
    Mit Romney
    Monopoly
    National Debt
    Occupy Wall Street
    Osama Bin Laden
    Partisanship
    Political Spectrum
    Pragmatism
    Prejudice
    Privacy
    Psychology
    Rachel Maddow
    Racism
    Recession
    Religion
    Republicans
    Rights
    Rush Limbaugh
    Sarah Palin
    Sean Hannity
    Semantics
    Sex
    Sexism
    Socialism
    Sources
    State Rights
    State Secrets
    Stephen Colbert
    Suicide
    Taxes
    Tea Parties
    Term Limits
    Theory
    Tom Tancredo
    Torture
    Unions
    Van Jones
    Wikileaks

    RSS Feed

Please check out my books!

  • Logic
  • About
  • Author
  • Books